Choosing a China Law Firm for a Supplier Dispute: Fixed Fee, Hourly or Contingency?
By the team behind ChineseCheck · updated 2026-11-15 · 7 min read
“Fixed or hourly?” is the first question buyers ask about Chinese law firms, and the right answer is “both, by stage”. The structure that protects you is fixed fees for information and the letter, capped hourly or contingency for litigation, and a written stop-loss between each stage.
Stage 1 — information: fixed fee per item
Before anything else, a PRC lawyer can do four things that no database can: ask the enforcement court what it has already attached in existing cases against the company; obtain the internal registry file (articles, resolutions, capital-contribution records) that turns a blank “paid-in capital” field into evidence; run a preliminary asset search on a sole shareholder; and compare the beneficiary account on your receipt with the company’s filed invoicing account. Each is a discrete task. Price each in writing. Treat a court-file enquiry as speculative — you are not a party to the other creditors’ cases and the court owes you nothing — and pay a fixed fee for the attempt, not for the result.
Stage 2 — demand: modest fixed fee
A law-firm letter to the registered address and legal representative, with a 7–15 day deadline. Published fixed prices run from US$199 to US$2,360 depending on who signs and what is included; the comparison shows the spread. Proceed only if no substantive reply and Stage 1 found something worth attaching.
Stage 3 — preservation and filing: capped hourly or contingency
Here the structures diverge:
Hourly. US$300+ per hour has been reported in Shenzhen. Workable with a per-stage cap and a defined deliverable (preservation application; complaint and first hearing). Without a cap, a US$216,000 dispute became a US$140,000 loss plus fees in one documented case.
Contingency (风险代理). The firm takes a share of recovery, capped progressively by 司发通〔2021〕87号: 18% of the first RMB 1 million, 15% from 1–5 million, 12% from 5–10 million, 9% from 10–50 million, 6% above. Often combined with a fixed engagement fee. A real quote for foreign-buyer non-delivery claims: US$563–1,127 fixed plus 18%.
The arithmetic that chooses
At US$1,127 fixed plus 18%, on a US$11,313 claim:
| Recovered | 18% fee | Fixed | Net to you | vs principal | | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | | 100% | 2,036 | 1,127 | +8,150 | 72% | | 50% | 1,018 | 1,127 | +3,512 | 31% | | 20% | 407 | 1,127 | +729 | 6% | | 0% | 0 | 1,127 | −1,127 | −10% |
Break-even is US$1,374 recovered — 12.1% of the principal. Maximum certain loss is the fixed fee. Run your own numbers in the calculator.
Eight questions before signing
- Is the percentage on amounts actually received, or on the judgment sum?
- Is it inclusive of tax?
- Does a negotiated settlement count as recovery? (It is the most likely outcome.)
- What does the engagement fee cover — investigation and demand only, or filing and first instance?
- Who pays court fees, preservation bond and translation; are they recoverable from the defendant?
- Does the engagement cover enforcement, or does that need a new mandate?
- What is the firm’s recovery record in this category — rates, not counts?
- Will the firm decline on contingency after its own assessment? A refusal is a professional read on recoverability, delivered free.
Before you ask for any quote
Send the file, not the story: the counterparty’s registered name, USCC, status, address, legal representative, enforcement queue and visible assets; your contract and full receipt; a dated timeline. The free check produces the counterparty part; the US$199 report adds the capital history, the asset table, the routes priced and the recipient check; the case pack organises yours. Then request an introduction to a lawyer whose licence number you can verify.
Sources