Situation 1 · paid, nothing shipped
Paid a Chinese supplier and nothing arrived. Here is the order of operations.
Most buyers lose weeks waiting for the next promise. The sequence below is what a PRC lawyer does on day one: pin the entity, lock the evidence, open the cheap routes, then decide whether the expensive ones can pay back.
First 72 hours
Do these before anything else
- Download the full remittance receipt (beneficiary bank, account number, reference) from your bank or Wise account — not the email summary.
- Open a recall request and a beneficiary trace / fraud report with your bank or provider today; ask in writing whether a window remains.
- If any part went through Alibaba Trade Assurance, PayPal or a card, file the dispute now and keep the case number.
- Export the complete chat history with timestamps and save emails as .eml with headers; screenshots are weak evidence in China.
- Send one short written demand by email: amount, what you require, a dated deadline. Then stop negotiating in chat.
- Run the free company check: registered name, credit code, status, enforcement queue, outlook, lawyer tier.
- Check your trade-credit insurance and bank fraud protection; notify now even if unsure — late notice defeats cover.
Steps
The playbook, in order
01
Pin down who you paid
Match the name on the invoice and contract to the mainland register and compare it with the beneficiary on your bank slip. An English trading name is not a registered name; the Chinese name and the 18-character credit code are. If the beneficiary is a person or a different company, the registered company can deny receiving the money — that changes the whole plan. Three-way name check.
02
Read the company’s own record
Status (active, revoked, deregistered), entity type (a one-shareholder company shifts the burden of proof onto the shareholder under Company Law Art. 23(3)), industry classification (a “manufacturer” classified as a wholesaler is a trader), address type (village or residential address), insured headcount, paid-in capital, and the 24 months of change filings before you paid — capital cuts, equity transfers, legal-representative swaps.
03
Read the queue ahead of you
Judgment-debtor and dishonest-debtor records, restriction orders on the legal representative, the total already in enforcement against your claim. Two cases worth 22× your claim at the same court means earlier creditors attach first; zero records with a current filing date means nothing public is ahead of you yet. What each list means.
04
Decide the lawyer question by rule, not hope
Four tiers: brief a lawyer now (HIGH/MEDIUM outlook, ≥ US$20,000); start with a law-firm demand letter (active company, outlook not LOW, US$3,000–20,000); pay for a fixed-fee fact check first, not a lawsuit (LOW outlook, ≥ US$10,000); use bank, platform and police routes (under US$3,000, or LOW under US$10,000, or a personal account). The free check prints the tier and the three next actions.
05
Price the routes before you pick one
For a RMB 210,000 claim: acceptance fee RMB 4,450, preservation RMB 1,570, enforcement RMB 3,050 (Order 481). Arbitration only if the contract names an institution. A contingency fee is capped at 18% of the first RMB 1 million. Then the break-even: at a US$1,127 fixed fee plus 18%, you must recover 12.1% of the principal to be ahead. Calculator.
06
Send the letter to the registered address
A letter to a website address is a letter to nobody. The registered address and the legal representative’s name are what the courier and, later, the court use. A licensed PRC law firm issues and seals the letter; you receive the sealed original, the English copy, tracking and sign-off. How the letter works.
07
Set a stop-loss
Stop if the receiving account is offshore, if the court confirms every identified asset is attached by earlier creditors, if neither company nor shareholder holds identifiable assets, or if projected cost exceeds a conservative estimate of recoverable value. Decide your minimum settlement before negotiating, not during.
Evidence
What each document proves, and the gap to close
| Record | What it proves | Gap or next step |
|---|---|---|
| Proforma invoice / contract | Contracting entity, quantity, price, delivery date, dispute clause, seal | Check the seal matches the registered name; find the delivery date and any arbitration clause |
| Full bank / remittance receipt | Amount, date, beneficiary bank and account number | Compare the beneficiary with the registered company; keep the account number for a recall or freeze |
| Supplier’s written confirmation of receipt | Admission that payment arrived and a promise to perform | Preserve the original email with headers to prove the sending domain |
| Chat export with timestamps | Promises, excuses, silence after a dated demand | Full export, not screenshots; note the last substantive reply |
| Business licence photo | Registered Chinese name and USCC the supplier claims | Verify against the register; a licence image can belong to another company |
| Your written demand with deadline | Date of refusal; supports interest and the letter | Send if not yet sent; keep delivery proof |
Routes & costs
Each path, what it costs, how long it takes
Court figures from State Council Order 481; price your own amount in the cost calculator.
| Route | Cost | Time | When it fits |
|---|---|---|---|
| Bank recall / trace / fraud report | A support ticket | Days | Always first. Low odds on old transfers, non-zero on recent ones; may flag the account. |
| Platform dispute (Trade Assurance) / chargeback | Free | Weeks to months | Any part of the payment went through the platform or a card. |
| Law-firm demand letter | US$249 here; US$199–2,360 in the market | 1–2 weeks incl. delivery | Active company, US$3,000+; fixes the demand and often moves a trader that is still selling. |
| Court claim (acceptance + preservation + enforcement) | RMB 4,450 + 1,570 + 3,050 for a RMB 210,000 claim, plus lawyer and bond | 6–18 months | Amount justifies it and something attachable exists; preservation first where assets may move. |
| Arbitration (CIETAC foreign-related) | RMB 20,000 for a RMB 210,000 claim | 6–12 months | Only if the contract has an arbitration clause. |
| Police report (contract fraud) | Free; counsel recommended | Uncertain | Money went to an account the company does not own, or a pattern across buyers appears. |
FAQ
Questions buyers ask at this stage
Scammed on Alibaba — can I get my money back?
It depends on how you paid. Trade Assurance payments go through Alibaba’s dispute process; card payments can be charged back; bank transfers can be recalled only if the funds have not left the receiving account. Off-platform transfers to a Chinese company are recovered, if at all, through that company — which is why the first question is who you actually paid.
The supplier keeps saying “next week”. When is it a breach?
When the agreed delivery date has passed, or when a written deadline you set has expired without delivery. Fix that date now from the PI or contract; it starts the limitation period and the interest clock.
Is a US$8,000 loss worth a lawyer?
Below roughly US$3,000, no — bank, platform and police routes beat any paid legal step. Between US$3,000 and US$20,000 on an active company, a law-firm demand letter to the registered address is the proportionate step. Above US$20,000 with a company that has something to attach, brief a PRC lawyer now. The free check runs this rule on your amount.
Should I report it to the Chinese police?
Chinese police distinguish a civil dispute from contract fraud by intent at the time of contracting; non-delivery and silence alone usually land as a civil dispute and are referred to the courts. A report becomes realistic when the money went to an account the company does not own, or the same account appears in other buyers’ complaints.
What does “found nothing” mean on the court records?
No record in the datasets searched on that date. Enforcement records are published weeks to months after filing — in one real file, filed in January, searchable in May. Read every nil with its date.