Comparison

Collection agency, Chinese lawyer, or facts first?

Three ways to spend money after a supplier takes yours. The table uses only published fee schedules with the dates they were read.

Published fees

What each route charges

RouteProvider (published)Fee basisFitsRead
Collection agencyOddcoll (China via Inter-Credit, Qingdao)19.5% success fee for “other regions”; €99/month or €799/year membership after 30 daysUndisputed matured invoices; no-cure-no-pay2026-11-14
Collection agencyDebitura (International tier)30% (US$100–999) · 18% (1,000–7,999) · 15% (8,000–74,999) · 10% (75,000–149,999) · 7.5% (≥150,000); +8 points at 12–24 months age, +15 points over 24 monthsUndisputed debts; tiers by whole amount, not progressive2026-11-14
Law firm (non-contentious)Clyde & Co China debt collection overview15% of amounts recovered (non-litigation)Larger commercial receivables2026-11-14
Law firm (litigation contingency)Any PRC firmCeiling 18% ≤ RMB 1M · 15% 1–5M · 12% 5–10M · 9% 10–50M · 6% above (司发通〔2021〕87号); fixed fees for letters and Stage 1Contested claims; preservation and judgmentRule text
Facts firstThis siteUS$199 fixed — registry, court record, assets, routes priced, 14-day planDeciding whether to spend on either of the above—

Published rates on the dates shown; terms change — read the provider page before relying on it. A contested non-delivery claim is not a “debt” a collector can chase; it needs the contract read and the counterparty verified.

Worked example: US$11,313 deposit, nothing shipped

A collection agency at 19.5% would take US$2,206 of a full recovery — and in this file the company already had RMB 1.76 million in enforcement ahead of the buyer and no visible assets. The agency’s letters would have joined a queue. A law firm quoted a fixed US$563–1,127 plus 18%: maximum certain loss US$1,127, break-even at 12.1% of the principal. The US$199 report is what showed the queue and the empty asset table — the information that decides whether either route is worth a dollar.

When a collector fits

  • The debt is undisputed and matured: an unpaid invoice for goods delivered and accepted.
  • The debtor is trading and reachable, and the amount is too small for litigation.
  • You accept a percentage and a membership fee for someone else’s persistence.

When a lawyer fits

  • The claim is contested (non-delivery, quality, agency) and needs a legal instrument — a letter, preservation, a judgment or award.
  • The company has something to attach, or the amount justifies finding out.
  • You want fixed fees per stage and a stop-loss.

What to do before either

Run the free check: registered status, the enforcement total against your claim, visible assets, red flags, and the four-tier lawyer rule applied to your amount. Then price the routes in the calculator. The decision usually makes itself.

FAQ

Collection questions

Do debt collection agencies work on China?
International platforms route Chinese files to local partners — Oddcoll to Inter-Credit (Qingdao), Debitura to a Ningbo partner — on no-collection-no-fee terms with a success share around 15–30% plus membership or age surcharges. They collect undisputed, matured debts; a contested non-delivery claim usually needs a lawyer, not a collector.
Is a success fee of 19.5% legal in China?
The 18% ceiling under 司发通〔2021〕87号 applies to Chinese law firms’ contingency fees, not to collection agencies, which are not practising law. Different rules, different actors.
What does a lawyer charge instead?
Fixed fees per item for letters and fact checks; hourly or contingency for litigation. The contingency ceiling is 18% of the first RMB 1 million. A fixed Stage 1 fee bounds your maximum certain loss — the break-even table in the report shows where you are ahead.
Why check the facts before choosing either?
Because both charge for effort, and effort against an empty company is wasted. A company already in enforcement for 22× your claim, with zero visible assets, will not pay a collector or a judgment; a trader that is still filing and selling often responds to a law-firm letter.