Comparison
Collection agency, Chinese lawyer, or facts first?
Three ways to spend money after a supplier takes yours. The table uses only published fee schedules with the dates they were read.
Published fees
What each route charges
| Route | Provider (published) | Fee basis | Fits | Read |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Collection agency | Oddcoll (China via Inter-Credit, Qingdao) | 19.5% success fee for “other regions”; €99/month or €799/year membership after 30 days | Undisputed matured invoices; no-cure-no-pay | 2026-11-14 |
| Collection agency | Debitura (International tier) | 30% (US$100–999) · 18% (1,000–7,999) · 15% (8,000–74,999) · 10% (75,000–149,999) · 7.5% (≥150,000); +8 points at 12–24 months age, +15 points over 24 months | Undisputed debts; tiers by whole amount, not progressive | 2026-11-14 |
| Law firm (non-contentious) | Clyde & Co China debt collection overview | 15% of amounts recovered (non-litigation) | Larger commercial receivables | 2026-11-14 |
| Law firm (litigation contingency) | Any PRC firm | Ceiling 18% ≤ RMB 1M · 15% 1–5M · 12% 5–10M · 9% 10–50M · 6% above (司发通〔2021〕87号); fixed fees for letters and Stage 1 | Contested claims; preservation and judgment | Rule text |
| Facts first | This site | US$199 fixed — registry, court record, assets, routes priced, 14-day plan | Deciding whether to spend on either of the above | — |
Published rates on the dates shown; terms change — read the provider page before relying on it. A contested non-delivery claim is not a “debt” a collector can chase; it needs the contract read and the counterparty verified.
Worked example: US$11,313 deposit, nothing shipped
A collection agency at 19.5% would take US$2,206 of a full recovery — and in this file the company already had RMB 1.76 million in enforcement ahead of the buyer and no visible assets. The agency’s letters would have joined a queue. A law firm quoted a fixed US$563–1,127 plus 18%: maximum certain loss US$1,127, break-even at 12.1% of the principal. The US$199 report is what showed the queue and the empty asset table — the information that decides whether either route is worth a dollar.
When a collector fits
- The debt is undisputed and matured: an unpaid invoice for goods delivered and accepted.
- The debtor is trading and reachable, and the amount is too small for litigation.
- You accept a percentage and a membership fee for someone else’s persistence.
When a lawyer fits
- The claim is contested (non-delivery, quality, agency) and needs a legal instrument — a letter, preservation, a judgment or award.
- The company has something to attach, or the amount justifies finding out.
- You want fixed fees per stage and a stop-loss.
What to do before either
Run the free check: registered status, the enforcement total against your claim, visible assets, red flags, and the four-tier lawyer rule applied to your amount. Then price the routes in the calculator. The decision usually makes itself.
FAQ